October 31, 2026 · 4 min read
Who school choice serves, and where access breaks
Few education debates are as charged as whether school choice serves Black and Latino families. Supporters point to strong parent demand and gains in some programs. Critics point to weak results in others, uneven access, and the risk to public schools. Both sides are describing something real. Here is what the evidence shows, with the caveat that many of the surveys come from organizations with a point of view.
What families say
A YouGov poll reported by The 74 found that 70.3 percent of Black parents supported education savings accounts, compared with 59.1 percent of white parents and 50.8 percent of Hispanic parents. EdChoice, an advocacy group, reports that more than two thirds of Hispanic parents have supported charter schools, vouchers, and ESAs across nearly 30 surveys since 2020.
Wording matters. Chalkbeat has noted that support among Black and Hispanic voters depends on how a question is asked. Polls show demand. They do not show results.
What the results show
Results depend heavily on the type of program.
- Charter schools. The latest national Stanford CREDO study found that Black and Hispanic students and students in poverty grew more than similar students in traditional public schools, though the gains were not enough to match their white peers. Quality varies widely. An earlier CREDO study of Texas found Black charter students lagging district peers in reading, and the national study found online charters did worst.
- Vouchers. Four rigorous studies in the District of Columbia, Louisiana, Indiana, and Ohio found that students using vouchers scored lower on tests on average. In Indiana, students who stayed in private school caught up by year four. An older New York City study found no average college-enrollment gain but a positive effect for Black and Hispanic students. Test scores are not the only outcome, and the long-term evidence is thinner.
- ESAs. These are newer and harder to study. Florida's account program began largely for students with special needs, and families use the flexibility in different ways.
Who actually uses these programs
Access is where the gaps show.
- In Arizona, the first universal ESA program, a Brookings analysis found the lowest-income communities had 20 recipients per 1,000 children, compared with 74 per 1,000 in the highest-income communities.
- In Texas, just over a quarter of voucher recipients were Latino, though more than half of public school students are. Three fourths of the accounts went to low-income students.
- In Florida's tax credit scholarship program, participants were most likely to be Hispanic (39 percent) or Black (28 percent), though that data is a year old.
- Homeschooling has diversified. Johns Hopkins researcher Angela Watson reports that as many as 40 percent of homeschooled children since the pandemic are Black, Indigenous, or people of color. One analysis found Black homeschooling rising from about 3 percent of Black students before the pandemic to 16 percent by October 2020.
What critics say
The NAACP opposes school choice initiatives, arguing they worsen racial and economic segregation, divert money from public schools, and lack accountability. Chalkbeat's review found little evidence that targeted voucher programs have increased segregation, though it said larger universal programs might. Critics in Texas also noted that many rural counties have no private schools at all, so a scholarship may have nothing to buy.
What would make programs work for more families
This is my perspective as someone who works on ESA vendor approval and compliance.
- Measure more than test scores. Track graduation, college enrollment, and family satisfaction.
- Report who is served. Publish participation by race, income, disability, and geography every year.
- Fund navigation, not just accounts. Families need help finding approved providers and understanding the rules.
- Build supply where there is none. Rural and underserved areas need microschools, online options, and co-ops, plus support for transportation.
- Hold every publicly funded school to the same standards.
- Protect public schools. Programs last when families see that traditional public schools stay strong too.
The honest answer to whether school choice serves Black and Latino families is that it depends on how it is designed. The programs that earn trust will be the ones that show their data and fix the access gaps.
Sources
- The 74: National poll finds overwhelming support among Black teachers and parents for ESAs
- EdChoice: Large majority of Hispanic parents support school choice policies
- Chalkbeat: Critics of vouchers say they are marred by racism and exacerbate segregation. Are they right?
- CREDO at Stanford: National Charter School Study III (2023 release)
- CREDO at Stanford: Texas statewide charter school study (2015 release)
- The Hechinger Report: Charter schools have improved, but many still fail students
- Education Next: More findings about school vouchers and test scores, and they are still negative
- Chalkbeat via City and State: Do school vouchers work? Here is what the research says
- EdChoice: How Florida families use ESAs
- Brookings: Arizona universal ESA program and who receives funds
- PBS NewsHour: The private school choice boom leaves behind many kids in public school
- EdChoice: What states tell us about who is using school choice
- Johns Hopkins Magazine: The homeschool trend
- Anderson (2022): Homeschooling Black Students During the Pandemic
- NAACP resolution on the harmful effects of school choice initiatives
- Dallas Observer: Critics warn vouchers in Texas could revive segregated schools
New insights, by email
More insights
October 31, 2026 · 4 min read
Common ground: what supporters and skeptics of school choice both want
School choice divides people, but polling and policy debates point to shared priorities: equal accountability, transparency, and real options for families. Here is where agreement exists and where it does not.
October 31, 2026 · 4 min read
How states can say yes to the federal scholarship tax credit, and make it work
One public tracker counts 31 states that have opted in to the new federal scholarship tax credit. Here is how the opt-in works, where the politics are shifting, and what helps states implement it well.