October 31, 2026 · 4 min read

How states can say yes to the federal scholarship tax credit, and make it work

Expanding accessProgram design

The federal scholarship tax credit starts on January 1, 2027, and it only reaches families in states that choose to take part. That makes the opt-in decision one of the most consequential school choice choices of the year. Here is how it works, where states stand, and what I think helps a state say yes and then do it well.

What the program is

The federal scholarship tax credit is also called the Educational Choice for Children Act, or section 25F of the tax code. It allows taxpayers to donate to a scholarship-granting organization, known as an SGO, and receive a federal tax credit of up to $1,700. The scholarships can support a range of private or public educational expenses, according to Ballotpedia.

It is not automatic. A state has to opt in, and one tracker notes that it happens one year at a time. Each state law designates who can make that election, which can be a governor, an agency, or a legislature.

Where states stand

As of October 27, 2026, one public tracker counted 31 states opted in, 2 governors who vetoed opt-in legislation, 2 states that declined, and 16 that had not yet decided. Treat that count as a snapshot, because it keeps moving.

The politics have shifted since the winter. In January, Education Week reported that 24 of the 27 states then opted in or on track were led by Republican governors, and that the governors of Hawaii, New Mexico, Oregon, and Wisconsin said they did not plan to opt in. Since then, according to the tracker, New York's governor opted in on October 9, and legislatures overrode vetoes of opt-in bills in Kansas, Kentucky, and North Carolina. Vetoes in Arizona and Wisconsin have stood.

Virginia shows how fragile a one-year election can be. The state was first to opt in, filed by the outgoing governor in January, and the incoming governor now decides whether to keep it.

Why some leaders hesitate

The hesitation is not always opposition to choice. North Carolina's governor vetoed an opt-in bill but said he intends to enroll once federal guidance is sound, so the program can invest in public school students most in need of after-school programs and tutoring. That is a concern about design and guidance, and design is something states can work on.

What helps a state say yes, and implement well

This is my perspective as someone who works on ESA vendor approval and compliance across many states.

  1. Decide early how SGOs are chosen and overseen. Virginia submitted a list of twelve SGOs and said it could change as federal guidance arrived. Mississippi and North Dakota said they would name theirs in the coming months. Clear criteria reduce uncertainty for families and providers.
  2. Make room for public school students. Because the scholarships can support public as well as private expenses, states can ask how SGO priorities, within the final rules, might fund tutoring and after-school help in public schools. That speaks directly to the concern above.
  3. Plan vendor approval and pricing before launch. Families can only use scholarship dollars where providers are approved and priced in line with the rules. In my experience, approval steps and pricing requirements differ a lot from one program to the next, and delays land on families first.
  4. Publish the data. Participation, how funds are used, and which providers are approved should be visible. Transparency builds trust with people who are skeptical.
  5. Build for durability. An opt-in that must be renewed yearly survives best when families across the political spectrum can see it working.

What to watch next

Watch for final Treasury guidance, how each state designates SGOs, and whether undecided states act before the January 1, 2027 start. Where opposition rests on design, there is room for conversation. Where it rests on principle, the most useful thing supporters can do is show strong implementation and honest data.

Sources

LinkedInEmail

New insights, by email

More insights

October 31, 2026 · 4 min read

Who school choice serves, and where access breaks

Black and Latino families often back school choice strongly, but the results and the access gaps depend a lot on the type of program. Here is what the evidence shows, what critics say, and what would make programs work for more families.

Equity and familiesProgram design