October 31, 2026 · 4 min read
Common ground: what supporters and skeptics of school choice both want
School choice is one of the most polarizing topics in education, so it is easy to miss how much people on different sides actually share. The most useful questions are practical ones: Who is accountable for results? Where does the money go? Can families actually use what they are offered? Here is what the evidence suggests about agreement, where real disagreement remains, and what a common-ground agenda could look like.
Where polling points to agreement
Every poll below comes from an organization with a point of view, so I treat these as signals, not settled facts.
- Equal accountability. A YouGov survey of 2,000 Wisconsin adults, fielded September 22 to October 9, 2026 and released by the City Forward Collective Action Fund, found 85 percent support requiring all publicly funded schools to meet the same accountability standards for student outcomes. Only 8 percent opposed. An earlier Change Research poll released by the same group found 80 percent of Wisconsin voters more likely to back a candidate who would hold all publicly funded schools accountable.
- Public school options. A YouGov poll for the yes. every kid. foundation found that over two thirds of respondents viewed public school open enrollment favorably, and about 60 percent believed that funding following the child would improve accountability, as reported by The Maine Wire. A separate poll summarized by the same outlet found open enrollment drew bipartisan support while vouchers and charter schools split along party lines.
- Education savings accounts. An EdChoice and Morning Consult survey, reported in June 2026, found 77 percent of self-identified MAGA supporters and 75 percent of liberals and progressives expressed support for ESAs. EdChoice advocates for school choice, so weigh that accordingly.
- Families want to use public funds. Research from the Johns Hopkins Homeschool Research Lab with RAND found that 68 percent of homeschooling parents either use or would use public funding, and 71 percent of those without access said they would use it if it were available.
Where real disagreement remains
- Funding for public schools. Some leaders say they support choice but not cuts to public school funding. North Carolina's governor took that position when he vetoed a bill in 2025.
- Who benefits. Michael Petrilli of the Fordham Institute has raised the concern that universal programs send substantial public money to families who do not need the help, which carries a political cost even if it brings more families into the coalition.
- Evidence on outcomes. A University of Arkansas professor, Christian Goering, told Talk Business and Politics that the best research over 25 years shows these programs have not improved student performance. Supporters such as Patrick Wolf, a school choice researcher at the same university, argue that universal programs cost states less per student. These claims are debated, and I would encourage readers to look at the studies themselves.
A practical common-ground agenda
This is my perspective as someone who works on ESA vendor and compliance programs.
- Same accountability for every publicly funded school. Public dollars should come with public results, whatever kind of school receives them.
- Transparency. Publish who participates, how funds are used, and which providers are approved.
- Strong vendor vetting. Fair, consistent approval and compliant pricing protect families and taxpayers.
- Access first. Equity means families can find, understand, and use their options. Navigation help matters as much as the dollars.
- Invest in public school options too. Open enrollment, tutoring, and after-school support strengthen the public system alongside choice.
- Design for durability. Programs that people on different sides can defend are the ones that last through elections.
Agreement on these basics will not settle every argument. It could change the conversation from whether choice should exist to how every program, public or private, earns families' trust.
Sources
- WisPolitics: City Forward Collective Action Fund Wisconsin poll (YouGov, Sept 22 to Oct 9, 2026)
- Urban Milwaukee: City Forward Collective release on Change Research poll (May 2026)
- The Maine Wire: YouGov and yes. every kid. national polling
- The Maine Wire: What Americans think about four major school choice policies
- Beecher Local: Survey on life skills and school choice (EdChoice and Morning Consult)
- Johns Hopkins Institute for Education Policy: New Data on U.S. Homeschooling
- Washington Examiner: School choice gains support from both parties in new poll
- Talk Business and Politics: Experts and studies offer variety of results for school choice models
- John Holt GWS: Emerging school models (reporting on Michael Petrilli)
- The Washington Times: States expand universal school choice
New insights, by email
More insights
October 31, 2026 · 4 min read
How states can say yes to the federal scholarship tax credit, and make it work
One public tracker counts 31 states that have opted in to the new federal scholarship tax credit. Here is how the opt-in works, where the politics are shifting, and what helps states implement it well.
October 31, 2026 · 4 min read
Who school choice serves, and where access breaks
Black and Latino families often back school choice strongly, but the results and the access gaps depend a lot on the type of program. Here is what the evidence shows, what critics say, and what would make programs work for more families.