October 31, 2026 · 4 min read
Rural and neurodivergent families: what school choice gets right and where it falls short
Education savings accounts began as a tool for students with special needs, and that is still where some of the strongest demand sits. For a child who is neurodivergent and lives in a rural community, the promise is real: flexible funds for tutoring, therapy, and a learning setting that fits. So are the risks. Here is what the evidence shows, what critics and supporters say, and what would help.
The demand is large
Florida's Family Empowerment Scholarship for Students with Unique Abilities funded 140,147 students in 2025-26, with an average scholarship of about $10,000, about $1 billion in funded scholarships, and more than 20,000 participating providers, according to Step Up For Students, which administers it. In older program data, about 53 percent of participants were on the autism spectrum.
Why rural families face extra barriers
Neurodivergence is not more common in rural areas. A research review found similar autism rates in rural and urban settings, but rural families report limited access to diagnosis and services, and they rely heavily on schools for screening and referrals.
The CDC notes a nationwide shortage of child mental health providers that is magnified in rural areas, and that 61 percent of areas with a mental health professional shortage are rural or partially rural. Telehealth can help, but coverage and reimbursement vary by state.
Then there is the school choice question. Critics say private schools are scarce in rural areas. Supporters, citing a Brookings analysis, say about seven in ten rural families live within ten miles of a private elementary school, and that rural families are about twice as likely to homeschool. Both can be true: a school within ten miles is not the same as one that can serve a child who needs a speech therapist or a behavior specialist. In the early years of Florida's ESAs, Step Up reported only 731 users in the state's 30 rural counties, out of more than 25,000 statewide. Participation has grown since, but rural families have often had to build a patchwork of services themselves.
The trade-off many families do not see
When families use a private option, they often give up protections under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, including the right to an IEP and due process. The Texas Council for Developmental Disabilities lists the loss of legal rights, limited accountability in the private sector, and the risk of segregation among its main concerns. The Coalition of Texans with Disabilities says many families do not realize they relinquish these rights.
Supporters respond that IEPs sometimes fall short even with good intentions, and that ESAs give families other paths to customization. Step Up's own blog has acknowledged that some states do not do enough to tell parents about the waiver. Everyone seems to agree the disclosure should be clearer.
What the outcome data shows, and does not
Satisfaction is high. Mississippi's legislative watchdog found 91 percent overall parent satisfaction and 78 percent of parents reporting progress toward their child's special needs goals. But that is parent-reported. The same office found the program lacked an accountability structure to ensure schools were providing needed services, that the state did not know what special needs services children received, and that about a third of responding nonpublic schools reported employing no special education staff.
Tennessee's comptroller reported parent satisfaction of at least 94 percent every year, but survey participation fell from 96 percent to 15 percent. Satisfaction numbers that few families answer do not tell us much.
What would help
This is my perspective as someone who works on ESA vendor approval and compliance.
- Plain-language rights disclosure. At enrollment, tell families exactly which protections they keep and which they waive, and give them a path back to a public evaluation.
- Faster, clearer approval for providers. Therapists and specialists must be approved vendors before families can use funds, and long approval delays leave children waiting.
- Build rural supply. Pair telehealth, mobile providers, microschools, and co-ops, and cover travel costs where there is no local option.
- Use public schools as service hubs. The CDC points to school-based health centers as a model for reaching rural children.
- Measure real progress. Track progress toward each child's goals, not just satisfaction, and invest in strong survey response.
- Disclose staffing and credentials. Every school or provider receiving funds for students with disabilities should publish its special education staffing.
- Do not weaken public special education. Many rural children will stay in district schools, and those schools need support too.
Supporters and critics agree on more than the debate suggests. Rural neurodivergent families should not have to choose between flexibility and protection.
Sources
- Step Up For Students: Family Empowerment Scholarship for Students with Unique Abilities (2025-26 fast facts)
- Next Steps: Florida scholarship program data, including share of participants with autism
- Rural Trends in Diagnosis and Services for Autism Spectrum Disorder (Frontiers in Psychology, 2017)
- CDC: Providing access to mental health services for children in rural areas
- Fordham Institute: Rural school choice is more common than you think
- Ballotpedia: School choice (rural access debate)
- Next Steps: A rural Florida family and ESA eligibility
- Texas Council for Developmental Disabilities: Vouchers and students with disabilities
- Coalition of Texans with Disabilities: Comments on ESAs for students with disabilities
- Disability Rights Texas: ESA implications for students with disabilities
- Next Steps: Choice programs and federal civil rights protections for children with special needs
- Mississippi PEER Committee: Review of the ESA program for students with special needs (2018)
- Mississippi PEER Committee: ESA program report highlights (satisfaction survey)
- WKRN: Tennessee comptroller report on the ESA pilot program
New insights, by email
More insights
October 31, 2026 · 4 min read
Common ground: what supporters and skeptics of school choice both want
School choice divides people, but polling and policy debates point to shared priorities: equal accountability, transparency, and real options for families. Here is where agreement exists and where it does not.
October 31, 2026 · 4 min read
How states can say yes to the federal scholarship tax credit, and make it work
One public tracker counts 31 states that have opted in to the new federal scholarship tax credit. Here is how the opt-in works, where the politics are shifting, and what helps states implement it well.